I have an essay in The Point magazine -- a Chicago-based magazine on culture and politics -- that I spent many months working on. It is about Americans abroad, the damage we do, the innocence we claim, the stories we tell -- and also, perhaps, the responsibility and solidarity we could take on. It's about Suzy Hansen's journalist memoir "Notes on a Foreign Country," -- and about Henry James, James Baldwin, and Omar El Akkad among others. And it has more auto-biography than I usually include in any of my writing.
I generally agreed with Hansen's critique of American imperialism, and I found the book thought-provoking. But I also found her framing and her tone off-putting, because of how self-centered it is and above all of how utterly humorless. Here is an excerpt:1997 GMP Historical Big One Eldora Speedway Kings Royal 18 Scale+Box1 43 Istmodels Barkas B1000 Caravan 1973 white brown
Hansen argues that her lack of awareness about America’s role in the world was structural, intentional—an ignorance that many Americans, particularly white Americans, wear like mental armor, allowing them to believe, against all evidence, that our political and military interventions abroad are always necessary, successful and well-intentioned. “I would never have admitted it, or thought to say it,”1955 Chrysler Ghia Falcon en 1 18 Escala de Minichamps 107143030Honda Vfr800P 2002-2008 Japan Police Bike 1 43 Diecast Model Set Of 2 With Case Hansen explains, “but looking back, I know that deep in my consciousness I thought that America was at the end of some evolutionary spectrum of civilization, and everyone else was trying to catch up.” Hence, she assumed that in Istanbul, she would assess how well Turkey was meeting certain U.S. standards (“democratization,” “modernization”); she would also think about “solutions” to Islam, because “that’s what Americans always do.”
Hansen occasionally mentions The Fire Next Time (1963), in which Baldwin describes the willful, 1 43 Kyosho Ferrari 250 GTO 24 Hours of Le Mans 1962Mercedes Benz 300D Papa Giovanni XXIII 1 43 Model RIOviolent blindness of white Americans, and their determination not to face “reality—the fact that life is tragic.” Baldwin himself left America for France and Turkey because he found life there false and unbearable, a physical and psychological assault. At least African Americans, he wrote, possess “the great advantage of having never believed the collection of myths to which white Americans cling: that their ancestors were all freedom-loving heroes, that they were born in the greatest country the world has ever seen, or that Americans are invincible in battle and wise in peace.” Hansen read this passage long before moving to Turkey,1 18 Minichamps Mercedes Benz SL Class Cabriolet 20081 50 CATERPILLAR 906H Compact Wheel Loader - Core Classics Series 85213 but one of her points is how often we can know something but not really accept it. She writes: “Even when I disagreed with America’s policies, I always believed in our inherent goodness, in my own.”
From Istanbul, Hansen traveled to report from Greece, Egypt and Afghanistan, only to discover from wry, patient locals that the crisis each country is currently undergoing can be explained by a history in which U.S. intervention figures prominently. In Afghanistan, Solido 1 43 Scale Metal Model - SO182 DELAHAYE 135 M 4048 blueE53 Scania Tractor with Boiler Semi-Trailer Wiking Box Empty Åshe attends a Fourth of July party at the American embassy. There is a billboard outside the embassy that reads: “the u.s. embassy would be grateful if any of our friends who have information on terrorist activity or threats to please come to this gate.” There is a five-by-seven-foot American flag made out of cupcakes. The red, white and blue balloons keep popping from the heat, setting the crowd of Afghans and Americans, fearful of snipers, on edge. General David Petraeus and the U.S. Porsche TURBO S 911 991 Gen. II Lave orange 2016 Minichamps 1 18LSC002A TRIUMPH TR6 1 18ambassador dodge difficult questions from Afghan guests and deliver platitudes.
This is all very well observed. A different sort of writer would have made something barbed and darkly funny of this scene. Hansen seems headed in that direction, but instead she stops, on cue, to wring her hands: “Those bland, company-man words. In Kabul these words sounded criminal. These were loveless, soulless words. How could we speak to Afghans like this? … No one believed in the words they were saying, CORGI TOYS 445 Plymouth Sports Suburban Station Wagon near mint in complete boxBROOKLIN BRK 84 1934 LA SALLE 350 COUPE 1 43and yet this language was about real things: flesh and death and war, people’s homelands, and their children.”
It strikes me as a luxury and nearly an affront to be as sentimental and naïve as this. It’s not that we shouldn’t sympathize with Afghans and others—it’s that such an expression of sympathy, in which one’s own guilt and shock takes center stage, isn’t worth much. Meanwhile, many of the people I’ve met out in the world who are really up against it—who by circumstance or choice live terribly exposed—wear the risks they run matter-of-factly,PLYMOUTH BARRACUDA HARD TOP GREENLIGHT HWY18005 1 18 DIECAST CARBentley Mulsanne Turbo R (1980) Diecast Model Car 44165 the bearers of what Baldwin calls an “ironic tenacity.” They are knowing, daring, uncomplaining. I guarantee you they waste no time being shocked by the platitudes of U.S. ambassadors.
Hansen notes that when Albert Camus visited New York in 1946, he wrote in his journal that America was a “country where everything is done to prove that life isn’t tragic.” Camus held that “one must reject the tragic after having looked at it, not before.”ClassicBus 04018A 1 43 LIAZ 677M WITH WHEEL 1967-2002 orange1 18 Jaguar XKR Cabriolet 1997 Maisto no box Hansen does the looking but not the rejecting. She remains transfixed by the tragic and her own response to it, casting pretty standard culture shock as emotional catastrophe. Her Turkish lessons are “soul-shattering.” In Cairo, she is “lonely and clumsy, wreaking havoc on things I knew nothing about.” In Afghanistan, “it was my mere existence, I felt, that did damage enough. I wanted nothing else but to withdraw myself.”
When I read this, a phrase of another writer immediately came to mind. “I hate tragedy,” wrote Waguih Ghali, a penniless alcoholic and suicidal Egyptian who, in self-imposed exile after Gamal Abdel Nasser came to power in 1956, wrote one of my favorite novels.NOREV 1 18 Mercedes Benz AMG GT C Roadster Diecast Model Metallic Yellow 183451Schuco 450002600 BMW 327 Coupé blue-grey Beer in the Snooker Club contains passages that still make me laugh out loud. Egypt, the Arab country I lived in for many years, has one of the best and darkest strains of humor I’ve ever encountered. It does not come natural to me but I have often witnessed its gift, the way it can lift the pall of fear and death. It’s the laughter of survivors, balanced right on the edge of hope and hopelessness.
And check out the rest of The Point, there are many great pieces of writing there.
- 1 18 Holden FE Special (Cascade White over Etna Maroon) Carlectables 18600
- Brooklin Models 1952 Allstate De Luxe Model 115
- KIT RENAULT DOMAINE 1956 CCC CLASSIQUES 1 43 NEUVE EN BOITE MONTAGE USINE
- DCP Kwik Kargo Peterbilt 379 w 53' Refrigerated Trailer 1 64
- 10688 Preiser Ho 1 87 Bateau à Moteur Riva Ariston avec Caractères comme Photo
- BX67-0,5 Märklin H0 Ac 3080 Locomotora Diésel Locomotora Diésel Tren de
- Fleischmann 4383 E-Lok BR 151 004-9 DB CARGO Ep.5 6 Lok des BW Nürnberg,sehr gut
- Bn300-0, 5 x MÄRKLIN H0 AC Tender 24 058 FM 809 for 800 Steam Locomotive DB,
- IXO 1 43 SMEAL 105 AERIAL LADDER AMERICAN US FIRE ENGINE HUNTERSVILLE USA TRF012
- 1 18 BoS Cadillac Fleetwood 75 Saloon 1958 lightbluee-metallic
- Mercedes SL65 AMG 45th Anniversary 2013 Carbon Colour 1 18 Model MAISTO
- Corgi 211s - Studebaker golden Hawk in excellent condition
- 1 18 GT SPIRIT GT702 KOENIG 512 BBi BB TURBO YELLOW model car FERRARI BB512
- Bx377-0,5 x Wiking 1 87 H0 Fw-Modell Opel + MB+ VW + Unimog Spazzaneve Nuovo
- Minichamps - Porsche 944 Cabriolet 1991 - 1 43
- PORSCHE BOXSTER STOLA 2003 - KIT ABC 1 43 MONTE
- Avion jouet DINKY TOYS 62g Long Range Bomber (28770)
- Zetor Crystal 12011 2WD Red Vintage Tractor 1 32 Model 4984 UNIVERSAL HOBBIES
- Fleischmann H0 4103 K Dampflok BR 03 094 der DB sehr gepflegt in OVP (CL173)
I just received a copy of HONDA SIVIC 1987 WHITE FIRST 43 F43-041 1 43, Yoav Di-Capua's new book on Sartre and Arab intellectuals (it is essentially an intellectual history of the post-colonial Arab world) and its cover is very, very cool. I very much enjoyed Di-Capua's last book, AUDI A6 AVANT 3.2 2006 C6 ATLASgrey METALLIC MINICHAMPS 400013011 1 43 KOMBI, a great historiography and was happy to meet him in Austin (where he teaches at the University of Texas) on the sidelines of South By Southwest a few years ago. It'll be some more rigorous reading than I'm doing now (I've been devouring Cixin Liu's The Three-Body Problem sci-fi series, see great reviews here and BBR 1 43 FERRARI 458 ITALIA SPECIALE 2013 red FUOCO MET. ART.BBRC132RF) but looking forward to it.
Also recently received are two books on Morocco (and Jordan) – it's relatively rare that you get serious and in-depth English-language scholarship on Morocco, so good to see that – and a collected volume edited by Alfred Stepan including many A-listers and friends (Rached Ghannouchi, BRITAINS 13 MOUNTED U.S. CAVALRY SOLDIERS VintageFOR CODE 3 KITBASH FDNY FIRE FAMILY TRANSPORT FOUNDATION 1 64 SCALECarrie Wickham, Nathan Brown, Monica Marks, Radwan Masmoudi, etc.) that looks at the Egypt vs. Tunisia question post-Arab Spring. With chapter titles like "The roots of Egypt's constitutional catastrophe", it's pure Arabist geek-bait.